Patients' revisions of their beliefs about the need for hospitalization

UMMS Affiliation

Department of Psychiatry

Publication Date


Document Type



Adult; *Attitude to Health; Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale; Coercion; *Commitment of Mentally Ill; Female; Follow-Up Studies; *Hospitalization; Hospitals, Psychiatric; Humans; Judgment; Male; Mental Disorders; Patient Acceptance of Health Care; Patient Admission; Patient Discharge; Psychiatric Status Rating Scales; Retrospective Studies; *Treatment Refusal; Eisenberg, Marlene M; Bennett, Nancy S; Mulvey, Edward P; Roth, Loren H


Health Services Research | Mental and Social Health | Psychiatry | Psychiatry and Psychology


OBJECTIVE: An influential rationale for involuntary hospitalization is that prospective patients who refuse hospitalization at the time it is offered are likely to change their belief about the necessity of hospitalization after receiving hospital treatment. The authors examine how patients changed their evaluations of psychiatric hospitalization following hospital treatment.

METHOD: The authors studied 433 patients who were interviewed about their hospitalization within 2 days of their admission to a psychiatric hospital; 267 of these patients were reinterviewed 4-8 weeks following discharge.

RESULTS: When reinterviewed at follow-up, 33 (52%) of 64 patients who said at admission that they did not need hospitalization said that, in retrospect, they believed they had needed it. Only 9 (5%) of 198 patients who said at admission that they needed hospitalization shifted to saying that they had not needed it.

CONCLUSIONS: Many of the patients who initially judged that they did not need hospitalization revised their belief after hospital discharge and reported that they had needed hospital treatment. However, perceptions of coercion were stable from admission to follow-up, and patients' attitudes toward hospitalization did not become more positive. Coerced patients did not appear to be grateful for the experience of hospitalization, even if they later concluded that they had needed it.


Am J Psychiatry. 1999 Sep;156(9):1385-91.

Journal/Book/Conference Title

The American journal of psychiatry

Related Resources

Link to Article in PubMed

PubMed ID