Invitation to a dialogue between researchers and clinicians about evidence-based behavioral medicine
Department of Medicine, Division of Preventive and Behavioral Medicine
*Attitude of Health Personnel; *Behavioral Medicine; Clinical Competence; Cooperative Behavior; Decision Support Techniques; *Diffusion of Innovation; *Evidence-Based Medicine; Health Knowledge, Attitudes, Practice; Humans; Physician's Practice Patterns; Physicians; *Research
Behavioral Disciplines and Activities | Behavior and Behavior Mechanisms | Community Health and Preventive Medicine | Preventive Medicine
BACKGROUND: Evidence-based behavioral medicine (EBBM) aims to improve the process through which best scientific research evidence can be obtained and translated into best clinical decisions regarding behavioral treatments to improve health.
PURPOSE: The objective was to examine some legitimate concerns raised by both clinicians and researchers about the evidence-based movement.
METHODS: This article begins with a discussion of clinicians' fears that EBBM devalues clinical judgment and the therapist-patient relationship, will be used to restrict practice, is unnecessary, and is based on research that is irrelevant to clinical decision making. Next we consider researchers' worries that EBBM neglects evidence not based on randomized controlled trials and ignores causal mechanisms.
RESULTS: We find that these fears, although understandable, largely reflect misinterpretations of the evidence-based movement. Further, it is suggested that behavioral medicine is in a unique position to enhance the evidence-based movement by encouraging increased attention to treatment mechanisms and to knowledge translation.
CONCLUSIONS: Clinicians, researchers, and, importantly, the public will benefit from the evidence-based movement by having a health care system that is built on solid grounds of evidence in determining which treatments should constitute the standard of care. A full partnership between clinicians and researchers is called for to generate the practical, rigorous evidence base needed to take behavioral health treatments to the next level of scientific support and implementation.
DOI of Published Version
Ann Behav Med. 2005 Oct;30(2):125-37. Link to article on publisher's site
Annals of behavioral medicine : a publication of the Society of Behavioral Medicine
Spring, Bonnie J.; Pagoto, Sherry L.; Kaufmann, Peter G.; Whitlock, Evelyn P.; Glasgow, Russell E.; Smith, Timothy W.; Trudeau, Kimberlee J.; and Davidson, Karina W., "Invitation to a dialogue between researchers and clinicians about evidence-based behavioral medicine" (2005). Preventive and Behavioral Medicine Publications. 101.