Comparing the Accuracy of Three Pediatric Disaster Triage Strategies: A Simulation-Based Investigation
Department of Emergency Medicine; Department of Pediatrics
Emergency Medicine | Medical Education | Pediatrics
BACKGROUND: It is unclear which pediatric disaster triage (PDT) strategy yields the best accuracy or best patient outcomes.
METHODS: We conducted a cross-sectional analysis on a sample of emergency medical services providers from a prospective cohort study comparing the accuracy and triage outcomes for 2 PDT strategies (Smart and JumpSTART) and clinical decision-making (CDM) with no algorithm. Participants were divided into cohorts by triage strategy. We presented 10-victim, multi-modal disaster simulations. A Delphi method determined patients' expected triage levels. We compared triage accuracy overall and for each triage level (RED/Immediate, YELLOW/Delayed, GREEN/Ambulatory, BLACK/Deceased).
RESULTS: There were 273 participants (71 JumpSTART, 122 Smart, and 81 CDM). There was no significant difference between Smart triage and CDM. When JumpSTART triage was used, there was greater accuracy than with either Smart (P < 0.001; OR [odds ratio]: 2.03; interquartile range [IQR]: 1.30, 3.17) or CDM (P=0.02; OR: 1.76; IQR: 1.10, 2.82). JumpSTART outperformed Smart for RED patients (P=0.05; OR: 1.48; IQR: 1.01,2.17), and outperformed both Smart (P < 0.001; OR: 3.22; IQR: 1.78,5.88) and CDM (P < 0.001; OR: 2.86; IQR: 1.53,5.26) for YELLOW patients. Furthermore, JumpSTART outperformed CDM for BLACK patients (P=0.01; OR: 5.55; IQR: 1.47, 20.0).
CONCLUSION: Our simulation-based comparison suggested that JumpSTART triage outperforms both Smart and CDM. JumpSTART outperformed Smart for RED patients and CDM for BLACK patients. For YELLOW patients, JumpSTART yielded more accurate triage results than did Smart triage or CDM.
Rights and Permissions
Citation: Disaster Med Public Health Prep. 2016 Apr;10(2):253-60. doi: 10.1017/dmp.2015.171. Epub 2016 Jan 8. Link to article on publisher's site
emergency responders, mass casualty incidents, triage, vulnerable populations
Cicero, Mark X.; Overly, Frank; Brown, Linda; Yarzebski, Jorge D.; Walsh, Barbara M.; Shabanova, Veronika; Auerbach, Marc; Riera, Antonio; Adelgais, Kathleen; Meckler, Garth; Cone, David; and Baum, Carl R., "Comparing the Accuracy of Three Pediatric Disaster Triage Strategies: A Simulation-Based Investigation" (2016). University of Massachusetts Medical School Faculty Publications. 1139.